
Credits: Stock photograph by Steven Rivera from Pexels
By Sandra Arntz
The Human Right to a Healthy Environment (HR2HE) has been receiving increasing attention at the international level as unprecedented heat waves, floods and air pollution are impacting people all over the world. This attention is reflected in, inter alia, resolutions adopted by the United Nations Human Rights Council and the United Nations General Assembly, as well as in last year’s Advisory Opinion of the International Court of Justice (paras. 387-393).
Besides attention at the international level, the HR2HE has gained attention at the regional and national level. Several regional human rights treaties already recognize the HR2HE. Within the Council of Europe, repeated calls have been made to recognize the HR2HE in a binding legal instrument both at the regional and the national level. In the Reyjavík declaration, the member states of the Council of Europe committed themselves to pursuing the implementation of the Recommendation of the Committee of Ministers which calls upon member states to actively consider recognising the HR2HE as a human right at the national level.
In the Netherlands, the HR2HE is not (yet) explicitly recognized in the Constitution. Although Article 21 of the Constitution imposes a duty of care on the government to protect the environment, the existing constitutional framework offers limited protection. This is primarily due to the constitutional prohibition on constitutional review of acts of Parliament and the government’s discretionary power in fulfilling its duty of care. As argued in my previous contribution on Article 21, these limitations, combined with the procedural and substantive limitations, inequalities and contradiction arising from reliance on other existing human rights that do not have the objective of protecting the environment, such as the right to life under Article 2 ECHR (European Convention on Human Rights) and the right to respect for private and family life under Article 8 ECHR, demonstrate the need for explicit recognition of the HR2HE in the Dutch Constitution.
However, recognizing the need for a HR2HE raises questions about how such a right should be constructed. What legal interests should the right protect? What would its added value be besides existing human rights? And what rights and duties would it entail, and for whom?
To answer these questions comparative constitutional research can offer valuable insights. As part of my doctoral research I have conducted a case study on how Portugal has shaped the HR2HE in their constitution. Portugal already recognizes the HR2HE in Article 66 of the Constitution for over fifty years and the questions regarding how the right should be constructed have been the subject of ongoing academic debate in Portugal.
Drawing inspiration from the Portuguese legal system and the academic debate in Portugal, particularly the contributions of Heloísa Oliveira and Carla Amado Gomes, this blog explores how some of the questions that arise when designing a constitutional right to a healthy environment could be answered. The present blog does not intend to describe how the Portuguese constitutional right currently operates - although parts of the current framework are reflected in this blog - but rather to provide an overview on how certain questions concerning the construction of the HR2HE should be answered according to the author of this blog. The answers to these questions can be used to construct the HR2HE both at the international, regional and national level.
Legal interests and added value
One of the main questions concerning the HR2HE is: what legal interests should the right protect? Drawing inspiration on Portuguese Environmental Law and the ongoing debate, this author believes that the HR2HE should protect the natural environmental components, such as air, water, biodiversity, ground and landscape, and against the adverse consequences of human interaction with these components, such as climate change, (noise) pollution and (chemical) waste.
Protecting these legal interests also highlights the added value of recognizing the HR2HE alongside existing human rights, such as the right to life and the right to family life. Unlike these rights, the HR2HE provides protection to the environment as a collective good. Such protection is important to prevent that environmental degradation will affect the enjoyment of other human rights. The relationship between a healthy environment and other existing human rights has also been stressed by the International Court of Justice in its recent Advisory opinion in para. 393: “a clean, healthy and sustainable environment is a precondition for the enjoyment of many human rights”.
Furthermore, the added value of recognizing the HR2HE lies in ensuring that the interests of protecting the natural components of the environment are afforded an equivalent level of legal protection as other legal interests protected by existing human rights. Consequently, the recognition of the HR2HE would require environmental interests to be treated as interests of equal legal standing when balanced against individual human rights, such as the right to property.
Rightsholders and duty bearers
Another important question concerning the HR2HE is who should be considered its rightsholders and duty bearers. As argued by Portuguese legal scholars, the HR2HE should grant everyone the right to a healthy environment while simultaneously imposing a duty on everyone to protect it. In this context, the term ‘everyone’ should encompass natural persons, legal entities, and the state.
The HR2HE should give rightsholders several demands towards duty bearers. These demands may concern refraining from activities that are harmful to the environment, taking concrete actions to protect the environment and/or to enact rules and measures to protect the environment.
The obligations arising from the duty to protect the environment correspond to these demands. Accordingly, duty bearers are required to refrain from activities that are harmful to the environment, take concrete actions to protect the environment and/or take normative actions to protect the environment.
The fulfillment of this duty will differ depending on respective capabilities. For example, unlike natural persons and legal entities such as companies and NGO’s, the state has a broad authority to enact normative measures, in the form of generally binding regulations, to protect the environment.
To determine what obligations arise from this duty in a specific situation, the environmental principles can offer guidance. The environmental principles have been developing at the international level since the Rio Declaration. They entail, amongst others, the precautionary principle, the prevention principle, environmental damage rectified at the source, the polluter pays principle and the integration principle.
Realizing the HR2HE
The last question this blog will address concerns how the HR2HE can be realized in practice. Rightsholders can exercise the HR2HE by participating in decision-making regarding the environment or, if this does not lead to a desirable outcome, by taking legal steps against rules, measures or concrete actions that harm or threaten the environment. These legal steps can be taken to either prevent such harmful actions or to require that certain rules are put in place or that certain measures or concrete actions are taken.
To illustrate, a citizen or a legal entity may, based on the HR2HE, challenge rules or decisions of the state. For example, by arguing that a particular norm or decision violates the HR2HE. Or, conversely, challenge the failure to make rules or act — think of climate cases like the Urgenda Foundation v. State of the Netherlands or the Verein Klimaseniorinnen Schweiz and Others v. Switzerland.
Since the HR2HE protects the environment as a collective good, the claim should relate to a real or abstract risk of harm to the natural components of the environment. The claim must therefore not relate to harm to existing rights such as the right to life or the right to family life; for such harm, you can seek redress by invoking existing human rights.
For rightsholder to be able to exercise the HR2HE certain conditions will be necessary. First and foremost, everyone must have access to information concerning the environment. This information is often possessed by companies and government agencies. A necessary condition to realize the HR2HE is that these entities share this information with everyone in an appropriate and understandable manner. In addition to having access to the correct and understandable information, it is a necessary condition of the HR2HE that opportunities for public participation exist. This public participation consists of several components. First and foremost, public participation should aim to prevent legal proceedings as much as possible. For this reason, everyone should be involved at an early stage in decisions regarding the environment. In addition to participation in decision-making, public participation can be aimed at protecting the environment through concrete actions, whether by individuals or by citizens’ organizations. These concrete actions may include, among others, raising awareness about the importance of protecting the environment in society, engaging in dialogue with decisionmakers regarding the protection of the environment, and advocating for the protection of the environment in legal proceedings. Finally, a necessary condition for the HR2HE in a constitutional democracy is access to courts when rights are violated. This access serves as the last resort when public participation does not yield the desired result.
In conclusion, the HR2HE should be designed to protect both the natural components of the environment and against the adverse consequences of human interaction with these components, such as climate change, (noise) pollution and (chemical) waste. Furthermore, the HR2HE should encompass both a right to a healthy environment and a corresponding duty to protect it, applying to natural persons, legal entities and the state. The right should grant everyone various demands against duty bearers, while the duty should impose various corresponding obligations on them. The nature and scope of these obligations can be further specified in a concrete situation through the application of the environmental principles. Finally, the realization of the HR2HE requires certain conditions, including ensuring access to information, public participation, and access to the courts.
Bio

Sandra Arntz is a PhD candidate at the Research Centre for State and Law (SteR), Radboud University. Her doctoral research focuses on the extent to which the human right to a clean, healthy and sustainable environment is protected in the Netherlands, and what the Netherlands can learn from the choices and considerations of countries that have already shaped a human right to a clean and/or healthy and/or sustainable environment.