Crónica de los Suicidios Anunciados: Considering Suicides of Asylum-Seekers in Mandatory Detention under the Right to Life

Credits: Hilal via pexels

By Oğuzhan Öztürk

This blog contribution draws on a conference presentation given at ‘Legacies, Limits, Future: 60th anniversary of the United Nations International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR), and the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights (ICESCR)’ at Károli Gáspár University in Budapest. The author’s attendance at the conference was facilitated with the aid of a generous conference attendance grant from the Netherlands Network of Human Rights Research (NNHRR).

1. Introduction to Chronicle of Announced Suicides

In ‘Crónica de una muerte anunciada’, Gabriel García Márquez tells the story of an announced honor killing. The twin brothers, Pablo and Pedro Vicario, repeatedly state that they intend to kill Santiago Nasar because he has dishonored their sister, Angela. Although everyone ignored these statements, the brothers ultimately killed Santiago Nasar. The story focuses on the unexpectedness of the obvious. This blog post discusses something similar to that story. I argue that the suicides of asylum-seekers in mandatory detention should be considered violations of the right to life under the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR). More specifically, I argue that they should be understood as expected outcomes of mandatory detention in harsh conditions, rather than simply as system failures. I develop this argument in two ways: first, living without dignity due to conditions of detention; and second, lack of access to adequate medical care, which can lead to a failure to prevent suicides. I develop this argument by explaining the doctrinal framework for attribution of the three-tier test and then applying this test to assess whether these suicides can be considered violations of the right to life and failures of the State’s duty of care. For this discussion, I use asylum-seekers in Australia as a case study. I have chosen Australia because of its mandatory detention policies since the early 2000s and the well-documented extreme conditions in its detention centres.

2. Human Rights Committee and Article 6 of the ICCPR

Article 6 of the ICCPR guarantees that ‘No one shall be arbitrarily deprived of their life’. The Human Rights Committee (hereinafter the Committee) explains that this provision covers intentional harm, as well as foreseeable and preventable harm or injury that may result in the loss of life, whether caused by an act or an omission.

The Committee’s recent expansion of the living-with-dignity trend is evident. In 2025, in the views of Fátima v. Guatemala, Norma v. Ecuador, and Susana v. Nicaragua, the Committee discussed and found violations of the right to life, in which minor victims were sexually assaulted, denied abortion, and forced into motherhood. In Fátima v. Guatemala, the Committee focused on the right to life with dignity and expressed that she suffered from stress, social stigma, and anxiety, resulting in two attempted suicides. The Committee highlighted that public authorities were aware of her attempted suicides, which were her way of escaping from forced motherhood. The Committee found a violation of the right to life, expressing that the forced motherhood caused by a sexual assault affected her mental, physical, and social health; moreover, it affected her life goals and ability to pursue education. In doing so, the Committee broadened its interpretation of living with dignity under Article 6 of the ICCPR.

3. Monnheimer’s three-tier Attribution test and its Application to violations of the right to life under the ICCPR

Building on this framework, I will now introduce Maria Monnheimer’s three-tier attribution test and apply it to the suicides of asylum-seekers in mandatory detention in Australia. Monnheimer’s test has three elements: knowledge of the life-threatening risk, the degree of control, and reasonable preventability.

 3.1. Knowledge

The first element is knowledge. In international human rights law, the general threshold is whether the State knew or should have known about the risk. However, for people deprived of their liberty, the Committee has placed a specific responsibility on States: they must know, or at least should know, about the health conditions of detainees in their facilities, to the extent that this can reasonably be expected. This requires providing a properly functioning medical service, regardless of States’ financial means.

In the context of asylum-seekers, this knowledge can be established at two levels. First, there is actual knowledge. For example, individual suicide attempts must be reported directly to the authorities in detention centers. Second, there is constructive knowledge. The Committee recognizes that States should know about detainees’ health conditions because they are required to provide proper medical services. The research shows how serious the self-harm problem is. Self-harm rates were almost 200 times higher in immigration detention centers, 220 times higher in alternative places of detention, and almost 400 times higher in immigration transit accommodation than in the general Australian population. At the constructive knowledge level, the authorities should have known about the patterns of self-harm in detention centers. This knowledge was available through medical evidence, previously reported incidents, Australian Senate reports, and NGO reports.

3.2. Degree of Control

The second element is the degree of control. More control over individuals means higher responsibility. To present the degree of control in asylum detention centers, I will compare them with maximum-security prisons. Gresham Sykes argues that modern prison systems replaced past physical brutality. However, they can still be just as painful. He identifies several ‘pains’ of maximum-security prisons: loss of liberty, loss of goods and services, loss of security, and loss of autonomy. NGO reports and the Committee’s Views show that asylum-seekers experience all these forms of deprivation.

More specifically, asylum-seekers experience these forms of deprivation in several ways. First, they lose their liberty due to mandatory detention. In some cases, they are detained for 5 years; in extreme cases, for up to 15 years. Second, they often lack access to basic needs, including electricity, water for cleaning, and sanitary pads for women and girls. Third, many asylum-seekers, especially women, have repeatedly expressed that they feel unsafe. This is partly because they share space with convicted people whose visas have been canceled and are waiting for deportation, and partly because of the actions of those responsible for protecting them, including security officers. Finally, they lose much of their autonomy in their daily lives. Therefore, asylum-seekers experience forms of pain and loss of control that are comparable to those experienced by prisoners in maximum-security prisons.

3.3. Reasonable preventability

The third and final element is reasonable preventability. The Human Rights Committee has noted that States must protect individuals’ health when they arrest or detain them. The Senate inquiry report provides an example at the individual level. A security officer who worked at the Manus Island detention center during the 2014 riot said that violence was inevitable. This was due to the poor conditions, overcrowding, and the Government’s declaration that newly transferred asylum-seekers would never be granted visas. The riot resulted in the death of Reza Barati and injuries to many other asylum-seekers. The Australian Senate Committee’s inquiry found that the events leading to the riot were foreseeable and preventable. This is a reflection on the purposefully created uncertainty and its impact on asylum-seekers, resulting in the death of an asylum-seeker.

4. Conclusion

At the institutional level, asylum detention centers can be understood as intentionally hostile environments. They are designed to discourage further arrivals and to pressure people who have already arrived to return. Therefore, the decline in mental health, the increase in self-harm, and the rise in suicides should be understood as foreseeable consequences of the detention system, rather than simply as failures of the system.

These foreseeable and preventable deaths should therefore be considered failures of the State’s duty of care and deprivations of life under Article 6 of the ICCPR. This brings me back to Márquez’s story. The question is whether these suicides are also, in a sense, announced and expected consequences. Given the conditions of detention centers, alongside the lack of access to basic needs and proper medical care, including mental health care, suicides of asylum-seekers are expected results, as the Vicario brothers announced what they plan to do at the beginning of their story.

Before concluding, I want to make one final point. I use the Australian mandatory detention system as a case study because of the extreme conditions documented there. However, the argument is not limited to Australia. It could also apply where asylum-seekers are detained in conditions that prevent them from living with dignity or maintaining their mental health, and where this results in suicides. Lastly, for those interested in further reading, my article on this research has also been recently published.

Bio

Oğuzhan Öztürk is a PhD candidate at the Grotius Centre for International Legal Studies at Leiden University, where they have been conducting research since January 2023. His PhD project examines the right to protest of refugees and asylum seekers under international law. He holds an LL.M. degree in International Law from the University of Amsterdam and an LL.B. degree from Atatürk University, Turkey. Prior to his research, he gained experience through various roles as an intern at the International Criminal Court’s Office of the Prosecutor and a member of the Sakarya Bar Association in Turkey.

Add comment